Living by Faith When Answers Are Incomplete: A Three-Session Study

Begin with a question you can name honestly

Choose one unanswered question or unresolved situation to keep in mind during this study. Write it as plainly as you can. It may concern a decision, a disappointment, or an experience you cannot yet explain. You do not need to force it into a general statement about faith. Naming the particular concern will help you notice what the passages address and what they leave unanswered.

Read Habakkuk 3 for the first session, Hebrews 11:1–16 for the second, and Mark 9:14–29 for the third. The complete chapter links let you examine each reading in its setting. Read before using the commentary, and return to the text when answering the questions. The answer guidance points to evidence in the passages; personal reflection may take longer and need not be shared publicly.

Keep a distinction between an explanation, a promise, and a responsibility. An explanation tells you why something has happened. A promise gives grounds for hope in what has been spoken. A responsibility identifies something you can faithfully do. These passages do not supply an explanation for every reader’s circumstances. They do help us consider whom we trust and how we respond while questions remain.

If studying with others, agree that no one has to disclose a painful story. Listen before suggesting an application, and avoid telling someone that a particular tragedy must have happened for a reason you can identify. The plan’s practices are invitations to prayer and reflection. They do not measure the strength of someone’s faith by how quickly uncertainty or distress disappears.

Session 1: Hear the fear within Habakkuk’s prayer

Habakkuk 3 begins as a prayer. The prophet says that he has heard the Lord’s speech and was afraid, then asks the Lord to revive his work and remember mercy in wrath. His appeal is directed to God from within fear. The opening does not require him to become emotionally untroubled before he speaks.

The prayer describes God’s glory and power through vivid images involving nations, mountains, rivers, and the sea. It speaks of judgment and salvation together, including God going forth for the salvation of his people in verse 13. Read those lines before moving to the better-known ending. The final confidence arises within a prayer that has confronted the seriousness of divine action and the vulnerability of the people.

The imagery should be received with care. The chapter attributes action to God, and we should preserve what it says without embellishing it into a picture of delight in suffering. Nor should the images be flattened into a reassuring claim that nothing threatening is really happening. Habakkuk’s trembling in verse 16 shows that the prayer’s grandeur has not erased the reality of fear.

The bodily language is unusually direct: the prophet describes trembling, quivering lips, and weakness in his bones. This detail helps a reader distinguish trust from the absence of physical distress. Someone can turn toward God while still feeling shaken. The passage gives words for that combination rather than requiring a performance of calm as the condition for prayer.

Session 1: The losses remain named

Verse 17 imagines the fig tree without blossom, vines without fruit, the olive crop failing, fields yielding no food, and flocks and herds absent. These are sources of sustenance, so the description concerns serious deprivation. The language should not be reduced to an ordinary inconvenience that a cheerful attitude can easily overcome.

“Yet I will rejoice in the LORD” follows that list. The prophet identifies the object of his joy as the God of his salvation. He does not announce in the next sentence that the crops have recovered or the stalls have filled. His confidence is directed to God while the losses named in the preceding verse remain part of the prayer’s setting.

The closing verse names the Lord God as his strength and uses the picture of a hind’s feet and walking upon high places. The image expresses enabled movement and strength amid difficulty. It is not a forecast that every reader’s immediate circumstances will become comfortable. Keeping the claim proportionate allows the verse to encourage without asking it to promise more than it says.

A useful response is to let lament and gratitude stand beside each other. You might name what is missing, ask for help, and give thanks for a specific expression of care you have received. Those actions need not be forced into a single emotion. The prayer’s movement offers room to address God honestly and to seek strength for the next faithful step.

Session 2: Faith is directed toward God

Hebrews 11 begins by describing faith in relation to things hoped for and not seen. The following examples make that language concrete. People offer, prepare, obey, journey, and wait. Faith is shown in responses to God, rather than treated as a powerful feeling that can be directed toward any result someone desires.

Verse 6 makes the relationship explicit: the person who comes to God must believe that he is and that he rewards those who diligently seek him. The chapter’s confidence is therefore personal and directed. It concerns approaching and trusting God. The examples should not be read as a technique for making an unrelated ambition certain merely by believing strongly enough.

The assigned reading includes a range of responses. Abel offers, Noah prepares an ark in response to a warning about things not yet seen, and Abraham obeys a call to go out without knowing where he is going. Their actions differ because the circumstances and words addressed to them differ. Faithfulness does not always take the same outward form.

When applying the chapter, first identify what each person is responding to. That question guards against imitating an action without the calling or situation that made it appropriate. A reader should not infer that moving to an unknown place is automatically more faithful than remaining where responsibilities require them. The passage commends response to God, not uncertainty pursued for its own sake.

Session 2: Acting before seeing the whole outcome

Abraham’s example gives particular attention to incomplete sight. He obeys the call to go out, then lives in the land of promise as a stranger, dwelling in tents with Isaac and Jacob. The passage describes him looking for the city whose builder and maker is God. His response is active, but its fulfillment is larger than what he presently occupies or sees.

Sarah’s example emphasizes judging the One who promised to be faithful. The confidence is attached to the reliability of the promiser. This matters for readers tempted to measure faith only by the intensity of their own certainty. Hebrews directs attention to God’s faithfulness while describing human response within particular promises.

Verses 13–16 say that these people died in faith without receiving the promises in their fullness, seeing them afar off and acknowledging themselves as strangers and pilgrims. The language of seeking a country and desiring a heavenly one gives their waiting direction. Their unfinished experience is not presented as proof that their faith was worthless.

That description does not mean they received nothing from God during their lives. The chapter has already described real acts and gifts. It distinguishes those experiences from the fullness still ahead. A careful reading can acknowledge provision already received and hopes still unfulfilled without making either cancel the other.

Session 2 extension: Faith does not produce one visible outcome

Read Hebrews 11:32–40 before leaving this session. The closing examples include victories and deliverances, then torture, imprisonment, deprivation, and death. All are included within the chapter’s witness concerning faith. Visible success alone therefore cannot be used as a reliable measure of who has trusted God.

This wider setting is especially important when offering encouragement to someone whose circumstances have not improved. A confident statement that sufficient faith always produces immediate rescue conflicts with the chapter’s range of examples. Hebrews preserves both God’s power to deliver and the fidelity of people who endure suffering.

For a group, discuss how this affects the stories you tend to tell. Do you only recognize faith when an account ends with recovery, promotion, or a solved problem? Can you recognize faithful conduct in someone whose story remains painful? The chapter invites a wider and more truthful attention to perseverance, without requiring you to explain why different people experience different outcomes.

Session 3: A father brings his son and his uncertainty

Mark 9:14–29 begins with a crowd, questioning, and the disciples’ inability to help a boy brought by his father. The father describes the child’s condition and says that he asked the disciples to cast out the spirit, but they could not. The scene concerns a particular child’s suffering and the people attempting to respond to it. Keep that personal setting in view as you read the familiar sentence about belief.

Jesus asks how long this has happened, and the father answers that it has been since childhood. He describes dangerous episodes and appeals for compassion: “if thou canst do any thing, have compassion on us, and help us.” His request contains both urgent need and uncertainty about what can be done. He brings that uncertainty into the encounter rather than disguising it.

The narrative explicitly describes a spirit and Jesus’ command to it. That is the account Mark gives. It does not authorize readers to diagnose a modern child’s illness from similar outward symptoms or to withhold ordinary medical care. The study’s focus is the encounter as narrated, including the father’s appeal and Jesus’ action.

Jesus’ reply in the KJV places belief before the father: “If thou canst believe, all things are possible to him that believeth.” The following exchange shows how the father responds. Read it as part of a conversation with Jesus, rather than detach the sentence as a guarantee that any person can obtain any chosen result through sufficient mental confidence.

Session 3: Belief and the need for help can be spoken together

“Lord, I believe; help thou mine unbelief.” The father’s answer is both an affirmation and a request. He does not wait until he can describe his trust as complete before asking Jesus to act. The words reveal a person reaching toward Jesus while acknowledging what remains deficient in that reaching.

The narrative then centers on Jesus’ authority. He commands the spirit to leave and not return. After the boy lies as if dead and many say he is dead, Jesus takes him by the hand and lifts him up. The father’s phrasing is not presented as a verbal formula that independently produces this result. Jesus is the one who speaks, takes hold of the child, and restores him to his feet.

The disciples later ask privately why they could not cast it out. In the KJV, Jesus answers with prayer and fasting. Their need for instruction continues after the public event. The passage invites dependence and learning, including for people who have already been following Jesus. It does not encourage them to conceal failure to preserve an appearance of competence.

For personal prayer, the father’s response gives a pattern of honesty: name the trust you can affirm and ask for help where trust is weak. You may also ask directly for relief or direction. The event gives grounds to turn to Jesus; it does not promise that repeating the father’s exact words will reproduce every detail of his experience in your situation.

Christ, the One to whom the father turns

Mark's account gives this plan its direct focus on Christ. The father appeals to Jesus for compassion, Jesus commands the spirit, and he takes the boy by the hand and lifts him up. The same chapter records Jesus teaching that he will be killed and rise again, while his disciples still struggle to understand. Their incomplete understanding does not change who is speaking to them. The reader is invited to bring need to Jesus and continue listening to him. Faith here is a relationship of trust and response to the One who acts, teaches, and receives an honest appeal for help.

Continue without forcing a complete explanation

Return to the question you wrote at the beginning. Has a passage changed the way you ask it, even if it has not supplied the explanation you hoped for? Habakkuk may help you pray without denying fear. Hebrews may help you recognize faithful action while a promise remains distant. Mark may help you ask Jesus for help without claiming that your trust is already complete.

Choose one action consistent with what you know is right. It might be keeping a responsibility, making an appropriate request for help, continuing a prayer, or correcting something you have said. Make the action proportionate to your actual situation. Faith does not require an unnecessary dramatic gesture to prove that uncertainty has been overcome.

If studying with others, end by asking what kind of support would be welcome. A practical offer, patient listening, or agreed prayer can serve someone whose question remains open. Leave room for that person to decline an offer. Companionship should not become another demand that they resolve the difficulty on someone else’s timetable.

An original closing prayer: God, help me turn to you with the truth of my need. Teach me to remember your faithfulness without pretending that every question is answered. Give me strength for the responsibilities before me, compassion for others whose stories remain difficult, and courage to ask for help. Lord Jesus, I believe; help my unbelief as I continue to follow you.

Sources and editorial note

• Habakkuk 3: prayer, trembling, and rejoicing

  First session follows the full prayer and keeps its closing trust within the setting of fear and possible loss.

• Hebrews 11: faith and unfinished fulfillment

  Second session focuses on verses 1–16 and checks the full chapter’s accounts of both deliverance and suffering.

• Mark 9:14–29 and its chapter

  Third session follows the father’s appeal, Jesus’ action, and the disciples’ need for further instruction. Scripture wording follows the KJV.

Prepared with AI assistance for Learn of Christ and checked against the passages and sources listed here. This revision has not received independent human scholarly review. Scripture quotations are from the King James Version unless another translation is named. Prayers and exercises are original examples.

How we prepare our study guides