Translation comparison

ESV vs MSG: English Standard Version or The Message?

The ESV and The Message sit at opposite ends of the translation spectrum. The ESV (2001) is a committee-made, essentially literal translation built for study, preaching and public reading; The Message (complete 2002) is Eugene Peterson's single-author paraphrase from the Hebrew and Greek, built to recapture the tone and energy of the originals in contemporary American speech. Most people who use The Message read it alongside a translation like the ESV rather than instead of one.

ESV approachFormal equivalence
MSG approachParaphrase
ESV published2001
MSG published2002

Word-for-word or thought-for-thought?

ESV: formal equivalence. MSG: paraphrase. See the full Bible translation chart.

Key differences between the ESV and MSG

Literal translation vs idiomatic paraphrase

The ESV follows the wording and sentence structure of the original as far as good English allows and keeps theological terms such as “propitiation” and “justification.” The Message does not try to match words at all. Peterson aimed to reproduce the effect of the text, so short phrases often become full sentences of explanation in modern imagery. In John 1:14 the Word “dwelt among us” in the ESV but “moved into the neighborhood” in The Message, and Psalm 23's valley becomes “Death Valley.” Charts place the ESV at 3 and The Message at 10 on a 10-point scale.

One voice vs a committee

The ESV was produced by a 14-member Translation Oversight Committee chaired by Lane Dennis, with J. I. Packer as general editor, more than 50 review scholars and an advisory council, revising the 1971 RSV. The Message is the work of one person, Eugene Peterson, a Presbyterian pastor with a master's degree in Semitic languages. NavPress had his drafts checked by two panels of evangelical scholars, but they confirmed that renderings were defensible readings rather than shaping the wording, which remained his.

Notes, verse numbers and textual decisions

The ESV prints textual footnotes: Matthew 17:21, Acts 8:37 and the Trinitarian clause of 1 John 5:7 appear only in notes, and the longer ending of Mark and John 7:53–8:11 are bracketed with explanations. The Message has no textual or translation footnotes, and its first editions printed no verse numbers so nothing would interrupt reading; numbered editions came in 2003 and 2005. Its handling of disputed passages generally matches modern critical practice, but because it paraphrases so freely, it is hard to tell which manuscript reading lies beneath the English.

Divine name and familiar passages

Where the Hebrew has YHWH, the ESV prints “LORD” in small capitals, and “GOD” where the Hebrew reads Adonai YHWH. The Message uses “GOD” in capitals for the name, so Psalm 23 begins “GOD, my shepherd!” The Lord's Prayer shows the gap clearly: the ESV keeps “Give us this day our daily bread,” while The Message prays “Keep us alive with three square meals.” Admirers cite lines such as “the unforced rhythms of grace” in Matthew 11:28–30; critics such as Warren Smith object to phrases like “as above, so below.”

Purpose and editions

Crossway presents the ESV as a Bible for close study, memorization and worship; it underlies the ESV Study Bible, the Lutheran Service Book and, in a Catholic Edition, several Mass lectionaries. NavPress calls The Message “a reading Bible” rather than a study Bible, meant for reading long stretches. Both are available with the deuterocanonical books: the ESV Catholic Edition (2018) and The Message Catholic/Ecumenical Edition (2013), whose extra books William Griffin rendered from the Latin Nova Vulgata. Both texts are copyrighted.

Side-by-side facts

FactESVMSG
First published20012002
Latest editionESV Text Edition: 2025 (68 words changed in 42 verses from the 2016 text)Current NavPress text (copyright 1993, 2002, 2018), sold with and without verse numbers
Translation approachFormal equivalenceParaphrase
Reading levelGrade 8 (Crossway's own estimate; others place it higher)-
PublisherCrossway, a not-for-profit publishing ministry of Good News Publishers (Wheaton, Illinois); HarperCollins in the UKNavPress (a ministry of The Navigators), represented by Tyndale House Publishers
TranslatorsA 14-member Translation Oversight Committee chaired by Lane T. Dennis, with J. I. Packer as general editor, aided by more than 50 review scholars and a 50-member advisory councilEugene H. Peterson, working alone from the Hebrew and Greek, with his drafts reviewed by two panels of Old and New Testament scholars
Old Testament sourceMasoretic Text as printed in Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia (5th ed., 1997), with the Dead Sea Scrolls, Septuagint, Samaritan Pentateuch, Peshitta and Vulgate consulted in difficult casesHebrew and Aramaic text of the Old Testament, which Peterson read in the original; the publisher does not name a specific printed edition
New Testament sourceCritical Text: UBS Greek New Testament (5th corrected ed.) and Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece (28th ed., 2012), departing from them in a few placesGreek New Testament, which Peterson rendered directly; no specific printed edition is named in the front matter
Canon66 books (Protestant); 73 books in the ESV Catholic Edition; Apocrypha in separately licensed editions66 books (Protestant); the Catholic/Ecumenical Edition (2013) has 73 books
Divine name (YHWH)“LORD” in small capitals; “GOD” in small capitals where the Hebrew reads Adonai YHWH“GOD” in capital letters where most translations print “LORD”
TraditionEvangelical Protestant, with Lutheran, Anglican and Catholic editionsEvangelical and mainline Protestant (Peterson was a Presbyterian pastor), read widely across traditions
Used byReformed, Presbyterian, Baptist and nondenominational evangelical churches; the Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod; many Anglican congregations; Gideons International; and, in its Catholic Edition, the lectionaries of India, England and Wales and ScotlandDevotional readers, small groups, youth ministries and preachers who quote it alongside a standard translation; rarely used as a pew or study Bible
CopyrightCopyrightedCopyrighted

ESV vs MSG: key verses compared

Verse text for MSG isn’t shown here because it renders passages as paragraphs rather than verse by verse.

VerseESV2016 text
Genesis 1:1In the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth.
Psalm 23:1The LORD is my shepherd; I shall not want.
Isaiah 7:14Therefore the Lord himself will give you a sign. Behold, the virgin shall conceive and bear a son, and shall call his name Immanuel.
Isaiah 9:6For to us a child is born, to us a son is given; and the government shall be upon his shoulder, and his name shall be called Wonderful Counselor, Mighty God, Everlasting Father, Prince of Peace.
Matthew 6:13And lead us not into temptation, but deliver us from evil.
Matthew 17:21Not in the main text (usually given in a footnote)
John 1:1In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God.
John 3:16For God so loved the world, that he gave his only Son, that whoever believes in him should not perish but have eternal life.
Acts 8:37Not in the main text (usually given in a footnote)
Romans 3:23for all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God,
Philippians 4:13I can do all things through him who strengthens me.
2 Timothy 3:16All Scripture is breathed out by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness,
Hebrews 11:1Now faith is the assurance of things hoped for, the conviction of things not seen.
1 John 5:7For there are three that testify:

ESV: The ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. All rights reserved.

What they have in common

  • Both work from the Hebrew and Greek rather than reworking another English Bible
  • Both are widely read by evangelical Protestants and available in editions with the deuterocanonical books
  • Neither includes the Trinitarian clause of 1 John 5:7 in the main text

Which should you choose?

Choose the ESV if…

  • You want to study passages closely or follow a sermon verse by verse
  • You want to memorize Scripture in wording shared by many churches
  • You need textual footnotes and study tools such as the ESV Study Bible
  • You are reading in a liturgical setting that uses the ESV

More about the ESV →

Choose the MSG if…

  • Familiar wording has gone flat and you want to hear passages afresh
  • You want to read whole books quickly to grasp their flow and tone
  • You enjoy vivid contemporary language for devotional reading
  • You want a companion to set beside a more literal translation

More about the MSG →

ESV vs MSG FAQ

Is The Message accurate compared with the ESV?

They aim at different kinds of accuracy. The ESV seeks closeness to the original words and structure. The Message seeks to capture tone and meaning, and its renderings were checked by scholars as defensible, but it often says more than the text says. Critics such as Michael Gorman and Warren Smith question particular renderings. Most pastors recommend The Message as a companion, not a replacement, for a translation like the ESV.

Can I use The Message for Bible study?

It can help you grasp the flow and feeling of a passage, but its publisher describes it as a reading Bible, not a study Bible. It has no textual notes, and its wording often cannot be traced to specific Hebrew or Greek words. For word studies or doctrinal questions, use a translation such as the ESV and keep The Message beside it.

Why does The Message say “GOD” instead of “LORD”?

Where the Hebrew has the divine name YHWH, most English Bibles, including the ESV, print “LORD” in small capitals. The Message uses “GOD” in capitals for the same purpose. Both conventions signal the personal name without spelling out a form such as Yahweh or Jehovah.

More translation comparisons